Changing your own oil used to be a rite of passage for anyone who enjoyed working on cars. But with modern vehicles becoming more complex—and time in short supply—more drivers are asking the question: should I still change my own oil, or is it better to have it done at a shop?
If you’ve been considering tackling your next oil change yourself, here’s what to think about before you grab the wrench or schedule that service appointment.
What It Takes to Do It Yourself
At first glance, changing your own oil seems simple: drain the old oil, swap the filter, and refill with new oil. But depending on your vehicle, it may be trickier than expected. Some newer cars have underbody panels that need to be removed just to reach the oil drain plug. Others use cartridge-style filters that require special tools to remove.
You’ll also need a few essentials:
- A reliable jack and jack stands or ramps
- An oil drain pan
- A proper-size wrench for the drain plug
- The correct type and amount of oil (based on manufacturer specs)
- A replacement oil filter
- Disposable gloves, rags, and a place to dispose of the old oil properly
If you don’t already have this equipment, the cost of buying everything may cancel out the savings compared to going to a shop.
The Case for Convenience
For many drivers, the biggest reason to have a shop handle oil changes is convenience. You don’t have to buy supplies, crawl under the car, or figure out what to do with the used oil. Most professional shops complete oil service in under an hour, and many include a basic inspection to check fluid levels, tire pressure, and other wear items.
If your vehicle has a maintenance reminder light or an oil life monitor, the shop can reset it for you—something many DIYers forget or aren’t sure how to do. It’s also one less thing on your to-do list, especially if you're short on garage space or free time.
Potential Pitfalls of DIY Oil Changes
While changing your own oil can save a few bucks and give you a sense of accomplishment, it also comes with a few risks. Stripping the drain plug threads, over-tightening the oil filter, or using the wrong oil type can lead to bigger problems. Even a small mistake—like forgetting to replace the oil cap—can lead to leaks or engine damage.
You also miss out on having a second set of eyes looking over your car. Many shops catch issues like small leaks, worn belts, or low brake fluid during a routine oil service. Catching these early can save you from more expensive repairs down the road.
When DIY Makes More Sense
If you’ve got experience, the right tools, and enjoy working on your car, there’s no harm in doing your own oil change. It’s a great way to learn more about your vehicle, and it can be satisfying knowing the job was done with care.
DIY oil changes also make sense if you live in a remote area or drive a vehicle that’s easy to work on and doesn’t require special tools. Just be sure to follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for oil type, change intervals, and torque specs.
But If You’re Unsure, Go to the Shop
If you’re not confident or don’t want to take chances with a messy driveway or a skipped step, professional oil service is the safer bet. Our technicians can do it quickly, correctly, and provide documentation that may be important for maintaining your vehicle’s warranty.
Plus, many modern engines are sensitive to oil quality and interval timing. Going too long between changes—or using the wrong oil—can lead to sludge buildup and internal damage.
Atlanta Car Care – Fast, Reliable Oil Changes in Atlanta, GA
At Atlanta Car Care in Atlanta, GA, we make oil changes quick, easy, and dependable. Whether you prefer to let the pros handle it or just don’t have the time to DIY, we’re here to keep your car running at its best. Stop by for expert oil service and a checkup that keeps you a step ahead of engine problems.